Starting in January, the book group I’m in will be reading four books by four different Indiana authors. I’m getting a head start, since I’m still an anxious nerd at heart (in elementary school, I would wake up hours before school started, just to make sure I wouldn’t be late; I could see my school from my bedroom window because it was right across the street). I always carry a book around with me in my purse, because I never know when I’m going to be standing in a long line, stuck in traffic, or just really really bored at work. If you are my employer and you’re reading this, I’m just kidding about the reading at work thing! Seriously, that was a joke. Please don’t fire me. I think you’re the best and I respect you! Let’s move on!
I just finished reading Slaughterhouse-Five by the Indiana native, Kurt Vonnegut. So, over the past week, I have been reading Slaughterhouse-Five in various public places – coffee shops, the long line at the post office, and at work (on my lunch break, when it’s totally appropriate for me to be reading). I have never read a book in public that has caused such a reaction as Slaughterhouse-Five. All the young people who saw me reading the book commented on how much they enjoyed reading it themselves. All the older people who saw me reading the book gave knowing chuckles, shook their heads at me, and said something annoying like, “Oh yes, I read that when I was young, too.” What they really meant was, “You’ll grow out of that phase soon enough, you immature youngster, you.”
What I wanted to say was, “Listen, Gramps. I’m not some Hot-Topic-shopping, self-proclaimed literature lover who actually only reads teenage vampire erotica, Dan Brown ‘books,’ and ‘books’ based on Dan Brown ‘books.’ I’m a professional, and I’m only reading this book for a book group discussion. I cut my teeth on Joyce, Maugham, and T.S. Eliot, and make my bones on Tolstoy, just for kicks.”
Even so, I’m going to have to side with the older generation on this one because by the time I finished the book, I was embarrassed that anyone had seen me reading it. It’s very Catcher in the Rye, if you know what I mean. I felt like Vonnegut tried a little too hard to be controversial and vulgar, and it seemed disingenuous to me. As one older adult told me, “You expect to read that kind of thing from a writer who is in his twenties, but Vonnegut kept writing that kind of thing into his old age.”
Part of my dislike of the book probably stems from the fact that I recently read Catch-22, and I think that novel deals with similar issues and topics in a far superior manner to that of Vonnegut. Also, Catch-22 was funnier and it didn’t make me want to eat my own head.
Final verdict: I may have read too many 19th century novels. Any novel compared with a Dickens novel seems crass and inappropriate, but Slaughterhouse-Five just didn’t seem worth all the blushing I did while reading it. Catch-22, on the other hand, was worth the blushing, I think. And now I need to go cleanse my palate with something saccharine. Does the Socialist Hoosier, Theodore Dreiser, count? Probably not…





























